Sherlock Homes Estate Agents
Manchester, M21
3.2/5, 67 reviews
57% recommended
68% sales valuation accuracy
71% sales fee satisfaction
91% lettings valuation accuracy
66% lettings fee satisfaction

“There is simply nothing positive I can say about sherlock ......”

Share on :
Sep 30,2015
Minithumbdown
By: 'Jones'
Sep 30,2015
2 people found
this helpful
There is simply nothing positive I can say about sherlock homes, the entire team are unhelpful and at times rude, they are simply money grabbing jobs worths and have no idea how to talk to clients and can clearly not run the company.

When my cousin and I first moved into the property it had not been cleaned and was full of damp and mould hiding behind the furnishings, when this as explained to Sherlock Homes and it took them 9 months to even come and assess the situation! When assessed it took them another month to come and fix the issue, leaving behind two holes in the wall, a broken bath fitting, and a stain on one of the bedroom carpets, when this was reported to Sherlock Homes I was informed that we had no proof that it was the workmen had done this and we as the tenants would need to sort these issues or we would be charge when we left the property. I therefore fixed and repaired what I could and when leaving the property in March 2014 the flat was immaculate, with newly painted walls, no mould, carpets cleaned, laminate floors scrubbed, and everything on the original itinerary cleaned and back into place (I even left my new mattress as the one they provided was horrendous!!) I asked if I could be present at the leaving inspection and was told I was more than welcome to do this and they would contact me to ARRANGE a time and date, this did not happen, instead I was told on the day of the inspection they would be there at 13:00 Hours, I was given 2 hours notice and I was working full time and on a 12 Hour shift when they left this message, I was told there was nothing they could do and it was only a request that I be there I didn't need to be there, because of this I was then charged £290 pounds to apparently clean the flat as there was dust on the intercom and crumbs under the toaster, there was items in the cupboard that were not on the itinerary and there was post on the floor (this was the wording used from the exit inspection)... I disputed this for several months asking for proof in the form of photographic evidence (they refused to provide) I then had to provide confirmation of my new residence, confirmation that I had transferred all bills and confirmation that any outstanding bills were being paid or paid before they would consider releasing my deposit.
I had simply had enough by this point and backed down and agreed to have the money deducted from our deposit, however by this point nearly 7 Months later I then had to provide all my evidence again as I had moved a further time. Once this was provided I was told I would receive the amount left roughly £305, however we are now 18 Months down the line and I am still no closer to receiving said deposit, as all members of the team have no idea what is happening and most of the time do not reply to emails, my last contact with them I was told that I had not paid my last bill of £54 pounds as we were leaving part way through the month, however before I could leave the property I had to go to the office in Chorlton to hand in both sets of keys and make the payment which I have a receipt for, they then went on to state that this was true but we still owed £305 which they couldn't tell me what this was for. I have a feeling they have looked at this wrong and that is actually what I am owed not what I owe them.

I would stay well clear of these so called 'estate agents'!! Horrendous experience and would never recommend them!
What agent could do to change your mind?
Far too much needs improving but heres a few Better communication between staff and their tenants Actually providing evidence as to how and why you came to these decisions When tenents provide evidence that they have not done something (holes in the wall) instead of making up some reason why I isnt your staff maybe just fix the issue, considering you find it very diffcult to provide evidence yourselves Give the tenant chance to rectify the problems before they leave the property (although I have proof there wasn't anything to rectify) Instead of lying and saying what the tenant whats to hear i.e once youve sent this in we can send out your cheque, maybe explain there are futher issues that need to be dealt with this reduces the amount of times the tenant has to ring
Attached Filesnbsp;
Comment on agent fees
Charged a ridiculous amount for admin fees when first entering the property Charged a further ridiculous amount when leaving the property without providing evidence as to why (toast crumbs on the side does not take ‚£260 pounds to clean!!!!!!)
Was this helpful? Yes
By: Sherlock Homes
Nov 30, 2015
Landlords do on occasion allow tenants to return to the property to make good any damage or cleaning. This is dependant on when the tenant requests to return and when any new tenant is due to move into the property. Some landlords do not allow tenants to return particularly where the works are excessive or where the landlord feels the tenants conduct throughout the tenancy has not been satisfactory. Again and more importantly - all tenants have the right to go to the TDS or whoever their deposit is registered with for them to decide what is fair. The agent does not profit or gain from a tenants deposit. Any charges made are transferred to the landlord to cover any costs incurred by him in making good his property at the end of a tenancy. Tenants may be frustrated concerning deductions and address their concerns with the agent and unfortunately some tenants do not appreciate that the agent is unable to refund monies the landlord has not authorised and for this reason it is important that they take up such disputes with the appropriate deposit scheme which is one of the main purposes of this scheme.
By: Sherlock Homes
Oct 06, 2015
Dear Gemma, We note your comments above and we are sorry that you were dissatisfied with the service provide. We note that you have not named any staff that you have dealt with an not been satisfied. If you would kindly do so, we will then look into your complaint further and address any training issues as necessary. You signed an inventory at the commencement of your tenancy agreeing to the condition of the property. Your deposit was protected by the TDS and this is highlighted within the tenancy agreement that you signed agreeing to the terms of. If you were not satisfied with the Exit Report, then of course you were entitled to raise a dispute with the TDS who protected your deposit. I also understand that we were waiting for evidence of your bills, one of which was a large amount of some hundreds of pounds. Whilst we appreciate that obtaining bills from the utility companies can be time consuming, this is a requirement of your tenancy and helps to ensure that your landlord is not contacted or indeed pursued for a debt that is not his responsibility. You were entitled to contact the TDS concerning any deductions imposed by your landlord. We appreciate that you state you were not happy about the charges to your deposit but we are unsure why you chose not to ask the TDS to consider your case. Had the TDS agreed with your view that any charges were not fair, your landlord would then have had to refund to you the same. Sherlock Homes Properties do not profit or gain from any deductions from a tenants deposit. Any charges to a tenants deposit is paid to the landlord in full in order for the landlord to make good any damages and cleaning that a tenant is responsible for.

Agent Response / Add a Comment

You can use this form to reply to the above review or a displayed comment on the above review.




Note: Your comment will not be activated until you click on the link in an email sent to your address as submitted in the form above. By clicking on Submit Comment you agree to receive an activation email from allAgents.


Opening Hours
Address

Sherlock Homes Estate Agents
58 Beech Road
Chorlton-cum-Hardy,Manchester
Greater Manchester
M21 9EG
01618818228

Performance statistics
Services Valuation Accuracy Fees Satisfaction Min Price of property reviewed Max Price of property reviewed
Sales 68% 71% £300,000 £300,000
Lettings 91% 66% £400 £1,300
Review statistics
From Landlords From Tenants From Vendors From Buyers Other
13 0 24 26 1 0 1 0 0 2
Areas covered
  • M21
  • M15
  • M16
  • Altrincham
  • M20
  • South Manchester
  • M19
  • M32
  • M45
  • M33
  • M28
  • M14
  • SK8
Services offered
  • Sales
  • Lettings
  • Block Management
  • Surveys
  • Conveyancing
  • Mortgage Advice
  • Home Builder
Members of
NAEA NALS TDS
Latest Properties

No Properties

“AVOID SHERLOCK SHAMBLES!...”

Share on :
Sep 12,2020
Minithumbdown
By: 'Luke'
Sep 12,2020
0 people found
this helpful
AVOID SHERLOCK SHAMBLES! Wish we had read reviews of this company beforehand. These people are not fit to run an estate agents. They are liars, thieves and charlatans. I truly hope people do not use this company and hope to hear about this companies closure ...
read full review
Was this helpful? Yes

“Avoid using these agents...”

Share on :
Mar 10,2020
Minithumbdown
By: 'Michael'
Mar 10,2020
1 people found
this helpful
I was with Sherlock Holmes for just short of a year but I have to say it was some of the worst customer service I have ever received. At the beginning I had no problems and the flat I was shown in January 2019 was perfect ...
read full review
Was this helpful? Yes
By: Sherlock Homes
Mar 18, 2020
View all comments (1)
Dear Michael. The agent does not profit nor gain from a tenants deposit. The balance goes to your landlord and it is your landlord who determines what is deducted from a tenants deposit. Equally your landlord insisted that you were kept to the terms of your tenancy. We note that this is disappointing but again as agent we have no say in such matters. As for repairs you state were delayed, unless essential or emergency repairs, the agent cannot proceed without the landlords authorisation. ...

“Lies, silence and aggression...”

Share on :
Jan 21,2020
Minithumbdown
By: 'Kay'
Jan 21,2020
6 people found
this helpful
My experience with Sherlock Homes is a catalogue of lies, silence and aggression for two terrible years. From the lies their agent told about the property - "yeah, that's a boiler; yeah, those are functional radiators" - to them refusing to protect my deposit - ...
read full review
Was this helpful? Yes

“AVOID LIKE THE PLAGUE...”

Share on :
Nov 16,2019
Minithumbdown
By: 'Jake'
Nov 16,2019
0 people found
this helpful
DO NOT DO BUSINESS WITH THESE PEOPLE! Firstly, read all the reviews here and on other sites. Then google * Sherlock Homes' and see that the proprietor has poor reputation. Note that the only positive reviews are for the sales department. Do not deal with the ...
read full review
Was this helpful? Yes
By: Sherlock Homes
Nov 19, 2019
View all comments (1)
Dear Mr Goodman We are disappointed to read your comments given that we explained at the outset that we were liaising with your landlord and awaiting his instruction. We reply as follows: Your personal attack and aggressive emails appear to be of a bullying nature with unfounded remarks. Unfortunately due to your repeated abusive and crude, vulgar, choice of language over the telephone, in the office in front of staff, customers and shockingly in front of children too, along with excessi ...

“Complete incompetents on a level never seen b......”

Share on :
Sep 28,2019
Minithumbdown
By: 'Jamie'
Sep 28,2019
0 people found
this helpful
Complete incompetents on a level never seen before. I had a viewing arranged for 11am, received an e-mail on the morning at 9am reminding me of the appointment. Got to the property on time, waited in the car park for twenty minutes, no sign of ...
read full review
Was this helpful? Yes

“I actually picked 1star but I still feel guil......”

Share on :
Sep 03,2019
Minithumbdown
Hamza
By: 'Akilu'
Sep 03,2019
0 people found
this helpful
I actually picked 1star but I still feel guilty because what this organisation deserves is less than that. They are the peak of unprofessionalism and systemic fraud. I moved out of one of their properties almost 6 months ago and still no deposit. I have been ...
read full review
Was this helpful? Yes

“Steer clear of these people!!!!...”

Share on :
Apr 08,2019
Minithumbdown
Helen
By: 'Cheryl'
Apr 08,2019
0 people found
this helpful
To say that their level of service to tennants is disgusting would be an understatement! I moved out 3 months ago and still, no deposit. Their staff doesn't seem to know what they're doing and I'm always being told that someone will call me back Steer ...
read full review
Comment on agent fees
Terrible
Was this helpful? Yes

“Great !...”

Share on :
Nov 14,2018
Minithumbup
By: 'Adam'
Nov 14,2018
0 people found
this helpful
James was really great at sorting everything out for our house move. Would recommend him and his team at Sherlock homes....
read full review
Comment on agent fees
James was really great at sorting everything out for our house move. Would recommend!
Was this helpful? Yes

“Excellent service from James...”

Share on :
Oct 08,2018
Minithumbup
By: 'Pauljohn4'
Oct 08,2018
0 people found
this helpful
Worked hard to get us into the property we wanted when we wanted. Stayed late to give us the keys on the agreed day. Very friendly and approachable....
read full review
Comment on agent fees
Standard
Was this helpful? Yes
By: Katherine Sparke
Oct 14, 2018
View all comments (1)
We had such a great experience with James!! He was quick to respond and always kept us updated. He made the experience beyond smooth and always went out of his way to explain things. Because of him I will definitely be returning in the future! ...

“Excellent service...”

Share on :
Oct 02,2018
Minithumbup
By: 'Dave'
Oct 02,2018
0 people found
this helpful
Brilliant service, prompt and professional. Built good rapport and went over and above by staying late to get things signed so we could get the keys early. Fully recommend sherlock homes after this experience....
read full review
Comment on agent fees
Similar to market value
Was this helpful? Yes

“Excellent customer service...”

Share on :
Oct 02,2018
Minithumbup
Tony
By: 'Amy'
Oct 02,2018
0 people found
this helpful
James was really friendly and very sympathetic to our stressful situation, we had less than two weeks to find somewhere to live and both James and Tony made the experience as stress free as possible. James answered all of our questions and gave a much ...
read full review
Comment on agent fees
expensive
Was this helpful? Yes

“First Rate Service...”

Share on :
Sep 21,2018
Minithumbup
Tony
By: 'Oli'
Sep 21,2018
0 people found
this helpful
Being new this I was relived and equally thrilled to have someone like Tony dealing with my property. From day one he knew how to improve things and gave me so much advice that helped. Friendly, professional and clearly very good at what he does. ...
read full review
Comment on agent fees
All very reasonable for the high level of service and professionalism provided
Was this helpful? Yes
By: Tony e'Silva
Oct 02, 2018
View all comments (1)
Hi Oli, Thank you for taking the time to leave this great review! All the best. Regards, Tony ...

“Helpful...”

Share on :
Sep 05,2018
Minithumbup
Hamza
By: 'James'
Sep 05,2018
0 people found
this helpful
Dealt with James on a recent property rent. Found him to be polite, knowledgeable and quick to communicate with us....
read full review
Comment on agent fees
Fees a little steep, but similar to others Agents.
Was this helpful? Yes

“Happy with my new flat...”

Share on :
Aug 31,2018
Minithumbup
Hamza
By: 'Sai'
Aug 31,2018
0 people found
this helpful
I've had a really positive experience with the agency. Everyone I have spoken with has been really nice, even from the first phone call. I was a little nervous anxious about the whole process of finding a flat since the market moves really quickly. James ...
read full review
Comment on agent fees
I think the fees were expensive. I don't believe agents should pass the cost of arranging tenancy onto tenants at all...
Was this helpful? Yes

“Excellent service...”

Share on :
Aug 28,2018
Minithumbup
Tony
By: 'S'
Aug 28,2018
0 people found
this helpful
Tony was excellent in assisting my move which was quite a complex situation however he was always helpful and willing to assist and made the move very easy. Thanks very much for this great service....
read full review
Was this helpful? Yes
By: Tony e'Silva
Aug 29, 2018
View all comments (1)
Hi Miss Hodson, Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review. Regards, Sherlock Homes ...

“Fast, Efficient Service....”

Share on :
May 30,2018
Minithumbup
Hamza
Tony
By: 'Laura'
May 30,2018
0 people found
this helpful
I can't recommend these guys highly enough. They were superb to deal with. Great communication throughout. Went above and beyond with little things like giving the keys to tradesmen etc. and they found me fabulous tenants. All the staff at the office are considerate and ...
read full review
Comment on agent fees
The same rates as most agents, but more for your money
Was this helpful? Yes
By: Tony
May 31, 2018
View all comments (1)
Dear Laura, Thank you for you comments, its always good to get good reviews for our hard work. Regards, Sherlock Homes ...

“Review by a landlord...”

Share on :
May 24,2018
Minithumbup
Tony
Hamza
By: 'Beech'
May 24,2018
0 people found
this helpful
I was using a rival Estate Agents to find new tenants but after waiting for viewings to materialise, thought I'd try Sherlock Homes instead. I'm glad I did :) I found Tony to be polite and professional, he arrived at the property and immediately knew how ...
read full review
Comment on agent fees
Are standard
Was this helpful? Yes
By: Tony e'Silva
May 25, 2018
View all comments (1)
Dear Landlord, Many thank for taking the time to leave this review. This shows the importance in good marketing! We looking forward to any repeat business. Regards, Tony ...

“113A Beech Road...”

Share on :
Apr 18,2018
Minithumbup
Tony
By: 'Fiona'
Apr 18,2018
0 people found
this helpful
I found Tony and the team extremely helpful. They kept me up to date through out the process with telephone calls and email...
read full review
Was this helpful? Yes

“Service excellence...”

Share on :
Apr 16,2018
Minithumbup
Tony
By: 'S'
Apr 16,2018
0 people found
this helpful
Excellent service and many thanks to Tony and his team for the support and quick response in letting my property....
read full review
Comment on agent fees
Good
Was this helpful? Yes
By: Tony
Apr 18, 2018
View all comments (1)
Thank you Mrs Bolton, happy to help as always. ...

“Fairly better than other staff.Helpful in responding to my ......”

Share on :
Feb 27,2018
Minithumbup
Hamza
By: 'Mo'
Feb 27,2018
0 people found
this helpful
Fairly better than other staff. Helpful in responding to my queries, but was unable to respond to all the queries for example where in the property the communal TV system is located....
read full review
Comment on agent fees
Bad (too much)
Was this helpful? Yes

“Antonio e'Silva is a Highly manipulative and dishonest individual. You ......”

Share on :
Feb 07,2018
Minithumbdown
Tony
By: 'Chorlton'
Feb 07,2018
2 people found
this helpful
Antonio e'Silva is a Highly manipulative and dishonest individual. You can see this yourself by the fact that he has applied all his fake reviews from a previous firm in London to the firm of Sherlock Homes in Manchester, where within 7 Days of taking the ...
read full review
Comment on agent fees
no comment
Was this helpful? Yes
By: Tony
Feb 13, 2018
View all comments (1)
Dear sir, Firstly, this is a national review site - naturally if I change company or location it will change on this site. Secondly, as stated before, your rent had increased twice in the last 12 years, once in August 2016 and now for the second time in Feb 2018, I can see why you'd be disappointed as you have been used to lower rents for so long. The decision to increase your rent did not come from me, rather your landlord, I invite you into my office to see proof if you so wish. I ...

“Really thrilled with how quickly and painlessly a maintenance request ......”

Share on :
Nov 17,2017
Minithumbup
Helen
By: 'Lauren'
Nov 17,2017
0 people found
this helpful
Really thrilled with how quickly and painlessly a maintenance request was completed by Helen who explained clearly what the plan of action was to resolve the issue, both myself and the other tenant were very reassured and happy with the service....
read full review
Comment on agent fees
Fees were pretty standard within the market
Was this helpful? Yes

“Hamza was very nice when we went for the flat ......”

Share on :
Sep 18,2017
Minithumbup
Hamza
By: 'Lena'
Sep 18,2017
1 people found
this helpful
Hamza was very nice when we went for the flat viewing then he was very professional and very responsive during the whole letting process! We really did appreciate his help!...
read full review
Was this helpful? Yes

“Avoid, use only if no alternative available. The Repairs department ......”

Share on :
Sep 06,2017
Minithumbdown
By: 'VickiD'
Sep 06,2017
1 people found
this helpful
Avoid, use only if no alternative available. The Repairs department is fine; they react promptly and well. The only annoying thing is that they require a detailed explanation for any broken switch while the switch in question is the cheapest model and designed to break ...
read full review
Comment on agent fees
They charge maximum for evreything
Was this helpful? Yes
By: Sherlock Homes Properties Limited
Sep 21, 2017
View all comments (1)
Dear VickiD We are sorry to hear that you feel disgruntled with the administration charge. Sherlock Homes are transparent with the charges which are included on the website, in the office and on correspondence sent to tenants. We write to tenants acknowledging their notice to quit their tenancy, confirm the amount of rent due to the end of the tenancy and highlighting the importance of cancelling the standing order mandate. We confirm within this correspondence that on failure to cancel the ...

“Rachael Hitchings - Lettings Manager at Sherlock Holmes was super ......”

Share on :
Jun 20,2017
Minithumbup
By: 'James'
Jun 20,2017
0 people found
this helpful
Rachael Hitchings - Lettings Manager at Sherlock Holmes was super efficient. She did everything she said she would do and more. I would recommend her to others...
read full review
Comment on agent fees
Reasonable
Was this helpful? Yes
By: Sherlock Homes
Jul 12, 2017
View all comments (1)
Dear James, thank you very much for your kind feedback. We are always glad to hear that you are happy with the service you received and especially happy to hear that you feel we have gone above and beyond expectations, Warmest regards from the team at Sherlock Homes ...

“I found Sherlock Homes professional and easy to deal with. ......”

Share on :
Jun 04,2017
Minithumbup
Hamza
By: 'Caroline'
Jun 04,2017
1 people found
this helpful
I found Sherlock Homes professional and easy to deal with. Hamza in particular was really quick to respond and very helpful. The tenant fees were a little steep but they were very upfront and honest and confirmed the total before I had to pay anything, ...
read full review
Comment on agent fees
A bit steep but nothing hidden
Was this helpful? Yes

“I have rented through Sherlock Homes for a number of ......”

Share on :
May 11,2017
Minithumbup
Helen
By: 'Rachel'
May 11,2017
1 people found
this helpful
I have rented through Sherlock Homes for a number of years and always found their service to be very good. When ever I have needed to report a problem within my property their response time has always been prompt and I have been kept up ...
read full review
Comment on agent fees
Agents fees were reasonable and in line with what other agencies charged.
Was this helpful? Yes

“I have always had excellent service from Sherlock Homes they ......”

Share on :
Apr 26,2017
Minithumbup
By: 'Barros'
Apr 26,2017
0 people found
this helpful
I have always had excellent service from Sherlock Homes they are improving year on year . I am glad that I chose to use them several years ago...
read full review
Was this helpful? Yes

“I like the way that I always being keep inform ......”

Share on :
Mar 21,2017
Minithumbup
Helen
By: 'Eva'
Mar 21,2017
0 people found
this helpful
I like the way that I always being keep inform about what is happening and when things will be done....
read full review
Comment on agent fees
I have no comment
Was this helpful? Yes

“Sherlock Homes is a terrible letting agency. While our landlord ......”

Share on :
Mar 11,2017
Minithumbdown
By: 'B'
Mar 11,2017
0 people found
this helpful
Sherlock Homes is a terrible letting agency. While our landlord let her property through them, they held our rent checks numerous times without giving the landlord the rent. They failed to communicate numerous visits in an adequate amount of time. When the landlord terminated her ...
read full review
Was this helpful? Yes
By: Sherlock Homes Properties
Mar 30, 2017
View all comments (1)
Thank you for your comments within your review. It is unfortunate that given the matter was dealt with swiftly once you brought it to our attention, you chose to write a review of this nature. The contents of the review are not totally fair and do not reflect the important factors or indeed a true picture. The Deposit was protected at all times. Unfortunately, as you are aware this Deposit transfer to the Landlord was missed and was merely an oversight, which we believe was due to not holding in ...
Staff picture Tony
(43)
No image available Helen
(8)
No image available Hamza
(8)
Staff picture Paul
(0)
No fees information available
Kindly note that legally, letting agents need to publish information about their tenancy fees, government-approved redress schemes and client money protection schemes on their website and on third party websites (on which agents are listed). For properties to lease/rent in England, agents need to keep this information up to date and precise on allAgents or specify within the property description.

Complaints Procedure

No procedure set.
Last updated at 11:08 AM 24/07/2017 by David Buckley

Awards won by Sherlock Homes Estate Agents, Manchester M21 9EG



Find the Best Agent to
Sell or Rent Your Home